I’ve been mucking around with Aquarionics’ commenting system for a while now. As much as I tend to whine about my Driving Test article becoming a mecha for all people who have failed their driving test, it’s become invaluable as an example of what happens to E2’s threading model, display and comment navigation once you get to ten or twelve comments deep. Amazingly the model’s holding up well, but the display was confusing (You couldn’t see which post a reply was to) and the navigation was confusing (People clicking ‘reply’ thinking they’re commenting on a post, when in fact they’re replying to a comment).
So, I’ve mucked around to it to make it a little more obvious (the aforementioned article being the best place to see the effect).
What do people think?